Madness Monday: Finding Jim Butler on the 1910 Census

I cannot find my great-grandfather’s household on the 1910 census.  His name is James Benjamin Butler.  He appears on other censuses as follows:

  • 1900:  James, in his father’s household in the Ball Ground District, Murray County, Georgia.
  • 1920:  “J. B. Butter” in the Ball Ground District, Murray County, Georgia.
  • 1930:  “James B. Butler” in Chatsworth, Murray County, Georgia.

He should be found in Texas in 1910.  His first five children were born in Quanah, Hardeman County, Texas between 1907 and 1916.  Moreover, his second son was born in Quanah on February 14, 1910.  So, 1910 in Hardeman County seems like a no-brainer.  The only problem is I can’t find him.

I’ve searched every permutation of his name that I can think of in both and FamilySearch (not just in Texas – the whole country).  James, J. B., Jim, Butler, Butter.   I’ve searched all Butlers born in Georgia in 1880, then again as a wild card search with the last name as But?er.  I’ve also searched for his wife, Maud Angeline, and his two oldest sons, Floyd David and James Benjamin, Jr, again with any name combination I could come up with.

I found his sister, Mattie (Butler) Sampler and her husband in Quanah.  His younger brother, William, lived with Mattie.  I would have thought that Jim’s family lived somewhere nearby, but I’ve browsed through every page of the census images for Hardeman County and they are nowhere to be found.

If anyone know where to find this family on the 1910 census, please leave a comment.  Also, please comment if you can think of any other ways to search.  I’m out of ideas.

Related posts:

Share this article!


  1. Pam Morrison Sinclair says

    Tonia, like you, I have looked and looked in Texas and every state between there and Georgia for the family in 1910. If you ever find them, let me know.

    I continue to search for the Jeremiah Patterson family in 1860.. One of my big brick walls. And of course, I was excited to connect James Butler to a sister in Rutherford County, NC before his move to Hall County and marriage to Rhoda Qualls. But I can’t find a connection for parents of James and Susannah Butler that takes them back to VA.

    So excited you have done so much with this!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge